Thanks for Visiting!

Register for free to get the full story.

Sign Up
Already have a Placer.ai account? Log In
Back to The Anchor

Luxury Versus Department Stores: Assessing the Impact of Prestige and Aspirational Shoppers

Thomas Paulson
Sep 29, 2023
Luxury Versus Department Stores: Assessing the Impact of Prestige and Aspirational Shoppers

Over the past year, we have written about luxury brands expanding their U.S. footprints and the transfer of luxury consumption by U.S. consumers to Europe as international vacations became a thing again. This week, we looked at the difference between visitors in 2019 compared to the last twelve months for the prestige luxury brands and the department stores, as shown below. (An important caveat to this analysis is that we are only looking at stores included in Placer, and we have excluded stores which may be located within dense areas, multistory buildings, or other such locations where visitation is not fully processed.) How to read the table is as follows: (1) between the time periods, visitors to Cartier increased by 121K, or +203%, due to both opening more venues and an +82% increase in visitors per venue; (2) those visitors that also visited a Macy’s at least 2 times were up +150% both due to additional Cartier stores in new markets and a +50% increase in consumers going into a Cartier; and (3) on an apples-to-apples basis, Cartier enjoyed a greater increase (+82%) than the Cartier visitor shopping Macy’s (+50%).

Luxury_Dept_Stores_092923

When we total the luxury brand visitors from our sample group, the increase was +21% all-in, or +1% on a per location basis, with that more subdued increase resulting from the large decline at Louis Vuitton. We suspect that visitors are down for Louis Vuitton due to a pullback by the aspirational luxury consumer (where the brand is more exposed), more cannibalization due to a large number of new locations, and more degradation from its customers vacationing internationally (versus buying luggage and other categories at a U.S.-based Louis Vuitton store). This same dynamic also appears to be a large weight on Macy’s luxury shopper. If the Louis Vuitton customer is removed from Macy’s luxury shopper mix, the remainder is flat on a per location basis, which is a slightly lower rate than the remainder of the luxury brands (+6%).

Unsurprisingly, the prestige luxury shopper is a more resilient one. This can be seen by comparing Macy’s -10% decline in prestige luxury shoppers (or flat excluding Louis Vuitton) versus the -22% decline among non-prestige luxury shoppers. As we would expect this shopper to be a much bigger spender at Macy’s than its average shopper, that helps bridge the gap between the -22% decline in shoppers and only a -8% decrease in sales during the first half of 2023 (additionally, less discounting and favorable product/customer mix are also meaningful contributors). Over the periods, comparable-store ticket was up +22.5%, and that demonstrates a shift in the business mix to bigger spenders.

Over the past two years, we have been monitoring Dillard’s outperformance relative to Macy’s. (Dillard's comparable-stores sales have increased +11% versus 2019, compared to an -8% decline at Macy’s). Dillard’s has been able to grow its prestige luxury shopper by +1%, or +12% excluding Louis Vuitton. And so that 12-point difference between Dillard's and Macy's prestige shopper counts likely goes a long way in explaining the 19-point difference between their comparable-store sales. However, looking at Census 2019, Mosaic, and Spatial.ai PersonaLive, we don’t see much support for this hypothesis. The table below shows the change in the shopper mix between the periods. The number of overall visitors fell by -15% since 2019, and as shown, segments that may hold prestige luxury shoppers (as defined by PersonaLive) like Suburban Sophisticates, Fast Track Couples, and American Royalty were down similarly. We often characterize Dillard’s as an idiosyncratic retail brand as its results generally are better than expected, and yet, hard to explain. We would point to this analysis as one more example of its idiosyncrasy.

DIllards_Personalive_092923

Schedule a Call

Required
Please enter your email
Required
Required

Thanks for reaching out!

I’ll be in touch soon

Go Back
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Thomas Paulson

Director of Research and Business Development, Placer.ai

Thomas Paulson spent 20 years as a Wall Street analyst and a member of asset management teams at AllianceBernstein and Cornerstone Capital, representing top-50 ownership positions including Target, Home Depot, Nike, Amazon, Google, and many more. He brings consumer related expertise and knowledge of enterprises in retail, CPG, financial services, telecom, and entertainment.

Schedule a Call
Related Articles

Black Friday’s Big Winner? Malls

Black Friday 2024 provided valuable insights into consumer behavior as we look ahead to 2025. Placer’s blog highlighted a +2.7% increase in Black Friday weekend visits compared to last year, with shoppers focusing on value while also seeking unique and differentiated products, evidenced by strong year-over-year trends at off-price retailers like HomeGoods, Marshalls, and T.J. Maxx. Pandemic-era categories like home furnishings and sporting goods may also be seeing signs of a resurgence.The standout takeaway, however, was the evolving role of malls. Mixed-use developments and placemaking, a key trend for malls heading into 2024, proved pivotal this Black Friday weekend. Open-air and indoor malls saw larger year-over-year visit increases (6.7% and 5.0%, respectively) than retailers across all property types (up 2.7%). This was a trend echoed by operators like Simon, further underscoring the mall’s continued relevance in modern retail.Retailers remain integral to malls, but seasonal attractions, entertainment options, and a more diverse tenant mix have transformed malls into community hubs and prime destinations for both residents and tourists. These attractions have a symbiotic effect, driving greater foot traffic to mall tenants compared to standalone stores of the same brands.Need evidence that this strategy works? Consumers are staying longer. Our data shows that open-air malls experienced a 7.2% increase in dwell time over Black Friday weekend, while indoor malls saw a 5.1% rise. As we've highlighted before, the longer consumers spend at a mall, the more likely they are to make a purchase.A strong box office undeniably played a role in Black Friday visit trends and dwell time. Our data shows a nearly 250% increase in visits to movie theaters this Black Friday compared to last year (below). However, the data also reveals that many malls with unique holiday attractions and effective marketing strategies experienced increased visits, indicating that mall traffic was driven by more than just blockbuster movies.Taken together, our data reinforces that malls have become more vital than ever to modern retail, evolving from traditional shopping hubs into multifaceted destinations that blend commerce, entertainment, and community experiences. Changes in tenant mix have introduced a diverse array of retailers, including digitally native brands, experiential stores, and unique local offerings, catering to broader consumer tastes. Increased visitor attractions, such as dine-in theaters, fitness studios, and immersive art installations, create compelling reasons that drive repeat visits for more than just shopping. Mall-focused events, from seasonal pop-ups to live performances, further enhance the draw by fostering engagement and creating a sense of occasion. This strategic evolution has positioned malls as essential anchors in the retail ecosystem, blending convenience and experience to meet the demands of today’s shoppers.

R.J. Hottovy
Dec 6, 2024